← All case studiesReplatform · Retention · Paid media

Seven-figure paint retailer, rebuilt on Shopify Plus

Guiry’s, Denver CO. Regional paint and decorating retailer with a stalled ecommerce channel and a Magento 2 install everyone had stopped arguing about.

Role
Ecommerce Manager
Timeframe
Jan 2022 - Sep 2024
Scope
Full channel · $720K/yr media
Stack
Magento 2 → Shopify Plus · Klaviyo
Guiry’s paint and decorating storefront at dusk
Tracked yearly revenue
$300K → $2.2Min 24 months
Conversion rate
1.9 → 2.6%sitewide
Klaviyo revenue
$25K → $300K+attributed annually
AOV · organic
+16% · 3×order value · traffic

The problem

A $300K online channel attached to a well-known regional retail brand. Strong offline reputation, negligible digital revenue, and a Magento 2 site that made every proposed improvement expensive enough to postpone. Email existed as a monthly newsletter. Nobody could say which products actually sold online.

What I did

  1. 01Migrated to Shopify Plus.Catalog, URL structure, and search equity moved intentionally rather than dumped. The platform decision was really a velocity decision: cheap changes mean more changes.
  2. 02Rebuilt collection structure and PDP content.Clearer collection logic, and product detail that answered the questions the store’s own staff got asked at the counter every day.
  3. 03Built the lifecycle program from scratch.Klaviyo welcome, post-purchase, and win-back flows, then a real promotional calendar with sequencing instead of ad-hoc sends.
  4. 04Raised AOV deliberately.Cross-sell placement, bundles, and threshold-based messaging - the tactics people skip because they aren’t exciting. Worth 16%.
  5. 05Scaled a $720K annual media budget.Grew acquisition spend while improving CAC and ROAS, with organic and lifecycle carrying more of the load as they matured.

What happened

Tracked yearly revenue went from $300K to $2.2M in two years. Sitewide conversion rate moved from 1.9% to 2.6% - a sitewide figure, not a single optimized landing page. Organic traffic tripled and Klaviyo went from roughly $25K to over $300K in attributed revenue.

What I’d tell you in the interview

The replatform gets the headline, but the retention program is what made the number durable. If I had to redo it, I’d build the flows before the migration, not after.

Dealing with something similar?

Hiring someone to own ecommerce, or need hands-on help with a project? Tell me what you’re working on.